The Butter Club

Butter for every hour of the day.

Small-batch whipped butter, fresh bread and a hot lunch, made in Laurens, NY.

Pre-order Free coffee survey
The Lunch Box Grilled cheese, soup of the day, and chips or an apple. Tuesday to Friday, 10 to 4. $11

Find your butter.

Tell us what you like to eat. We'll match you with a butter, and you get a free coffee at the counter.

Which flavors pull you in?
How adventurous are you with flavor?
Butter goes best on…
What brings you by?
How'd you find us?

Optional. We read every one.

Last one. Who's the coffee for?

Your butter is

Honey

Plan an event
The Butter Club · Free coffee
One coffee, on us.
Show this screen at the counter. One per person. 114 Main St, Laurens · Tue to Fri, 10 to 4.

Events and catering

Parties at the shop, butter boards, lunch boxes for the office, breakfast for a crowd. Tell us what you're thinking and we'll put together a plan.

What kind of event?

Say hi.

Questions, wholesale, collabs, or just to tell us what you thought. We answer everything.

Follow @thebutterclubny

Schedule a pickup.

Tap + on anything you want, then pick a day and time at the bottom. No payment now.

Tuesday to Friday

The Lunch Box

Grilled cheese, soup of the day, and chips or an apple

Contains milk and wheat. Ask about today's soup.

$11

The butters

Five whipped butters, sunrise to midnight. Small batch, high-quality butter. $11 each, 4 oz.

Honey

Butter, local honey, a pinch of salt

Contains milk

Daybreak

Beet root, Earl Grey and honey

Contains milk

Meadow

Nettle and garden herbs

Contains milk

High Noon

Carrot, turmeric and black pepper

Contains milk

Midnight

Black garlic and sesame

Contains milk and sesame

The whole day

One of each, all five butters

Contains milk and sesame

$50
Available now

The holiday box

Everything we love, in one box. Made for gifting.

Contains milk, wheat and sesame

$80
  • All five butters
  • A jar of sea salt
  • A jar of wildflower honey
  • 1 lb ground coffee
  • 2 lb flour

Order for pickup or drop-off, or grab one at the shop.

From the kitchen

Baked fresh every morning.

  • Side of whipped butter

    Any flavor. Contains milk (Midnight also contains sesame)

    $1

  • Mini milk roll

    Contains milk, wheat, eggs

    $1

  • Chocolate chip cookie

    Contains milk, wheat, eggs

    $3.50

  • Shortbread

    Contains milk, wheat

    $3

For the pantry

A few New York favorites we keep on the shelf.

  • Wildflower honey

    Sunshine Bees Apiary, jar

    $12

  • Syracuse Salt

    Syracuse Salt Co., jar

    $10

  • Stagecoach coffee, 1 lb

    Stagecoach Coffee, Cooperstown. The same coffee we pour at the counter

    $18

  • Farmer Ground flour, 2 lb

    Farmer Ground Flour, stone-milled all-purpose

    Contains wheat

    $8

Your order

Fill this out and pick a day and time. We'll text you to confirm, then send a payment link. Nothing is charged until we confirm.

Nothing yet. Tap + on anything above.

    Pickup or drop-off?

    Lunch Box: Tuesday to Friday, 10 to 4.

    Our kitchen handles milk, wheat, eggs and sesame.

    $0No payment now. We'll text to confirm, then send a payment link.

    Merch, coming soon

    Hats, shirts and a few things for the kitchen.